English
  • English
  • Dutch
  • German

Why Cybersecurity Is No Longer One Talent Pool

Cybersecurity is no longer a single hiring discipline. Employers looking for cloud security, identity and access management, application security, security operations or governance expertise are competing for different combinations of experience, technical knowledge and professional judgement.

The UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology and Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport's September 2026 cyber security labour market research shows that demand and recruitment difficulty vary across specialisms. More than half of cyber security businesses that had recruited reported at least one hard-to-fill vacancy, while the skills sought ranged from governance and risk management to security testing, secure architecture and incident response.

For employers, the distinction matters because a broad security job description can attract the wrong candidates, distort salary expectations and lengthen the search for the expertise the organisation actually needs.

Why one security brief misses talent

Cybersecurity is often treated as one function with a common candidate market. In practice, it spans prevention, detection, response, assurance and secure technology design. These responsibilities overlap, but they are not interchangeable. A cloud security professional may not have the hands-on experience to investigate an incident, just as a security operations analyst may not have designed an identity architecture or embedded security into software development.

When a vacancy combines several responsibilities without identifying the priority, employers can unintentionally describe multiple jobs in one. A brief may ask for cloud infrastructure knowledge, penetration testing, incident response, access management, policy ownership and senior stakeholder advice. Few candidates will have equal depth across all of them, and those who do may be beyond the role's intended level or salary.

Recruiters can then assess candidates against inconsistent expectations, compare different types of experience and reject people who could suit a more clearly defined position.

Specialisms draw different candidate markets

Cloud security professionals work across platforms, architecture, infrastructure and the controls that protect services and data. Employers may need experience in a particular cloud environment, secure workload design, monitoring or risk management. The required depth depends on whether the role focuses on engineering, architecture or oversight.

Identity and access management focuses on authentication, authorisation, privileged access and identity lifecycle management. Roles may require experience with identity platforms, directory services, access governance or integrating controls across an organisation.

Application security candidates understand how software is designed, developed, tested and deployed. Their work can include secure coding, threat modelling, application testing and vulnerability management, often alongside development teams. This is not the same profile as a general infrastructure security specialist.

Security operations roles are centred on monitoring, detection, triage and response. Depending on seniority, candidates may work with security information and event management platforms, endpoint detection tools, threat intelligence, incident investigation and response procedures.

Governance, risk and assurance professionals focus on how security is directed, measured and evidenced. Their work can include risk assessment, policy, audit, control frameworks, supplier assurance and reporting to senior stakeholders. The joint DCMS and DSIT research identified governance and risk management among the specialisms associated with hard-to-fill vacancies. These are distinct professional markets, even where the roles sit alongside technical security teams.

IT Jobs Watch's November 2026 vacancy data put median advertised salaries at £75,000 for UK cloud security roles, £75,000 for UK identity and access management roles, £55,000 for UK SOC Analyst roles and £75,000 for application security roles in England. The samples and geographic coverage differ, so these figures are indicative rather than directly comparable. They show why employers should not assume one salary benchmark applies across cyber roles.

Consider a brief combining five different jobs

Consider a technology business seeking a senior cybersecurity hire. Its draft brief asks the successful candidate to secure cloud infrastructure, manage identity and access, review application vulnerabilities, lead the security operations centre and own governance reporting. The organisation describes this as one senior security position because all five responsibilities sit under the same department.

A recruiter may find candidates with strong experience in one or two areas, but the shortlist will look inconsistent. A cloud security architect may be less experienced in SOC leadership. A GRC manager may understand risk and assurance but have limited hands-on engineering experience. An application security specialist may be highly effective with development teams without having led enterprise-wide incident response.

The first step is to identify the business problem. Is the organisation trying to reduce cloud exposure, improve response, strengthen identity controls, secure software delivery or establish better governance? If several outcomes are required, decide which is essential immediately and which can be supported by colleagues or developed over time. The responsibilities may justify more than one hire.

Candidates need a clearer professional identity

The same lack of definition affects candidates. A CV that presents every task as an equal specialism can obscure where a professional offers the greatest value. A concise account of the environments, problems and level of responsibility helps distinguish practical expertise from exposure to a technology or process.

Rather than simply claiming cloud security experience, candidates should explain whether they designed controls, secured workloads, managed configuration risk or advised on architecture. Incident response experience should clarify whether they supported investigations, led response or owned the wider capability.

Candidates need not narrow their experience artificially. They should present their strongest area clearly and show how adjacent skills support it. In October 2026, ISC2 announced a Cyber-AI Workforce Coalition to develop a toolkit helping employers hire, develop and organise cybersecurity talent as AI changes roles and skills. The initiative reflects the need to define capabilities rather than rely on broad job labels.

Hiring needs sharper briefs and benchmarks

A useful cybersecurity brief starts with outcomes, not an exhaustive list of technologies. Hiring managers should define the risks the role will address, the decisions the person will own, the systems they will work with and the level of hands-on delivery expected. They should separate essential requirements from desirable experience and make clear whether the role is primarily engineering, operations, architecture or governance.

Salary benchmarking should follow the same discipline. The IT Jobs Watch figures above cover different job titles, vacancy samples and, for application security, England rather than the whole UK. They should be treated as directional evidence rather than a definitive pay scale. Seniority, platform expertise, sector exposure, location and the scope of accountability will all affect an individual offer.

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport's October 2026 Digital and Technologies Jobs Plan, drawing on the joint DCMS and DSIT Cyber Security Skills in the UK Labour Market 2026 report, found that only 16% of core cyber security job postings in 2025 were open to candidates with less than one year of relevant experience, down from 25% in 2022. Meanwhile, 64% required two to six years of experience. Employers seeking experienced specialists should recognise the limited entry-level pipeline and consider how realistic their experience requirements are. Where appropriate, adjacent technical experience, demonstrable capability and structured development can widen the available talent pool.

Unfilled gaps create wider technology risk

An open vacancy can leave important work with already stretched teams. Security engineers may cover operational monitoring, developers may carry more responsibility for application vulnerabilities, and technology leaders may have less visibility of risk. This can create unclear ownership and delay improvements.

The NCSC's November 2026 Annual Review recorded 1,831 reports of cyber attacks affecting organisations during the year, with 337 incidents requiring support from its incident management team, 80 of them nationally significant. ENISA's September 2026 workplace skills survey found that 85% of employees surveyed were interested in improving their cybersecurity skills, while 26% identified lack of time as an obstacle to training. Together, these findings underline both the demand for effective incident response and the importance of developing workforce capability.

Treating cybersecurity as one talent pool makes recruitment harder and can leave the business problem unresolved. A precise view helps employers identify missing expertise, assess it and decide where flexibility is possible.

Building stronger specialist IT security teams

Effective cybersecurity recruitment begins with understanding the work behind the job title. As specialist requirements continue to develop, employers need a clear view of the skills available in the market, the experience that genuinely matters and the expectations that will attract the right candidates. Michael Bailey Associates supports organisations with specialist IT recruitment, helping clients define requirements and connect with talent whose experience aligns with the role. For organisations reviewing their cybersecurity hiring needs, a focused conversation can be a useful starting point.

19 November 2026

Why Cybersecurity Is No Longer One Talent Pool

05 October 2026

Contract or Permanent: Building the Right IT Team for 2027

10 September 2026

Why the IT Talent Market Is Moving Faster Than Most Hiring Strategies Can Keep Up With